Cheap LED Strips : A Viable Alternative

I have F series and I think they’re great! Choosing the right tool for the application is critical.
Honestly, I forget why I went Samsung strips instead of Bridgelux. It’s all over on the RIU discussion about strips, if anyone cares to look. Probably I was worshipping at the foot of the vaunted lm561c diodes and the price difference at the time was negligible. Maybe there was something about nominal length of strip vs actual, and I was planning a very length limited lighting plan. Oh well, none of that matters now.
That baking sheet is the ticket, though, for anyone building from scratch. When you run strips low enough, you don’t need a heatsink but they do add a lot of stability. Setting all that aside, however, I spent way too much time cutting neat little pieces of aluminum bars when I could have just screwed the suckers down and called it a day!

10 Likes

or old construction road sign :wink: lol, but i have gone down the fussing route as well

8 Likes

Can anyone tell me why it looks like the color of my strips shift when I lower or raise the power?
It’s almost like they’re changing from cool white to warm white.

1 Like

OMFG. I’m repurposing that sucker right now!

4 Likes

I’m in the process of getting rid of all of my COBs. Too dangerous I feel. I just don’t like having that kind of power density with the thermal runaway potential that LEDs have. I’ve already seen them burn apart thermal epoxy and set fire in the past. They’re OK when things work how they’re supposed to. The minute a fan dies or something they become a hazard.

Is digikey the only supplier? I need the 11" strips @700ma. Looks like stock is getting low, maybe because they’re switching production to the gen3 strips.

10 Likes

ah currently they seem to be, cutter out of australia i believe carries them as well edit… they do but the old ones

Here’s one version of mine. I may remodel with a baking sheet, though. That shiz is clean!

@lefthandseeds Use octopart or findchips to compare prices and don’t be afraid to haggle.

14 Likes

Same. I use the 17k lumens strips like these only in 3500K.

https://www.digikey.com.au/product-detail/en/samsung-semiconductor-inc/SI-B8VZ91B20WW/1510-2229-ND/6676693

I have found them to be excellent and easily a match for the Bridelux COB setup I had previously.

If kept cool I have fed them up to 3.5 amps without a problem other than more heat and sliding scale of efficiency L/W wise.
They ARE too expensive though so these strips look like a better bet for the next build I am going to do.

Just to emphasise this point here is SkyWalker OG at 6 weeks from popping and 14 days into flower. No dwarfism issues going on here ay? :grin:

All I find is that I need to do more canopy management that previously, but hey, small price to pay for not having a 1000w HID bulb get wet and go postal in your face!

I have seen this with both the Cree and Bridgelux COBs! I think it’s the Ledle plastic housing and connector that causes this… and I have seen them fully smoking/charred. Also they pump out the heat, not anything like HID but still the need to keep them away from the canopy for fire safety reasons is a real issue. And screw all those fans/heatsinks etc. I think thermal runaway is much less an issue than with individual LEDs in a string. I have not seen either COBs or strips suffer from this, even when I have had long strings of them in parallel and lost one or two. they have just seemed to deal with the extra current and not gone into meltdown.

14 Likes

Heres what I think about a 30w led square panel.

10 Likes

I’m not sure how this “adds” to the discussion… other than you don’t like your panel…

Okay ??? but you don’t share what it is, who makes it, or what its supposed specs are, or what you paid, all in a thread discussing cheap viable alternatives.

So if you would like you could share that info if you think it adds to the discussion, otherwise i’ll ask to get that and this post removed just cause its not really the point of this thread.

21 Likes

Hey Mr.Sparkle,

I really enjoy reading your grow logs! Intriguing :slight_smile:

I have this driver which I bought 10 X 10w cob strips (cheap ones) but I’m trying to figure out how many gen2 strips it can run?

5 Likes

None… That’s a 12v driver the EB series run at 19.5v or 39v for the 1120mm ones.

You would need a new driver.

10 Likes

Damnit, ok, thanks mate :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Yea… We figured that out huh?

4 Likes

Well no you had a hlg-320h-36b if it had been an “A” model you would of had a good possibility that it would of worked, Kayoes on the hand yeah that just won’t work.

2 Likes

I guess the discussion should come up on drivers and what can be paired with these EB series strips.

The Bridgelux EB Series Gen 2 strips run at two voltages

19.5v for the 280mm and 560mm ones
and 39v for the 1120mm ones

So your drivers must be capable of that as a base.

Now how many strips vs what driver your selecting or have this is how it breaks down.

The 280mm strips are 19.5v at 350ma nominal
560mm ones are also 19.5v but at 700ma “just a doubling of the 280mm essentially on the current side”
and the 1120mm are 39v at 700ma which again just another doubling but of the 560mm ones but on the voltage side.

So lets throw up some scenarios

Say you decide on a XLG-200-L-AB
Its stats are that its a 700ma driver but can run between 350ma-1050ma potentially
Its voltage range for constant current mode is 142v-285v

Insert math…
for the 560mm strips 285v / 20v = 14.25 strips rounded down to 14 "why 20v when the strips are 19.5v, im factoring in potential over driving and safety margin "
But base at max that driver could run 14 of the 560mm strips at there nominal current of 700ma, and because the driver can be pushed hard “if desired, but not necessarily recommended” it could even run them at 800-900ma each. The wiring for these strips though would be just a straight series connection.
On the minimum side not that any of us would be doing so with a 142v it could run 7 of the 560mm ones in series.

Now lets say we wanted to use the 280mm ones, them being at 350ma a piece and still 19.5v, we would need to parallel chain two series strings together to get up to that 700ma the driver put out, so those 14 strips max and 7 strips min of the 560mm ones now becomes 28 and 14 respectively, they would be wired up where you have two equal chains of strips that connected in series on the respected sides, but those two chains are connected in parallel to the driver causing the amperage to split between the two. Now side note say one strip utterly fails or gets broken completely causing all the current to go to the other operational chain, even though they are rated at being able to take double the current, and could potentially take more you have a chance of burning out a strip on that side as well. Would i be worried no, but its a minute possibility and even still if you have to replace two 280mm strips what’s the cost $6 ?

So lets continue on and say you wanted to use the 1120mm ones, at 39v at 700ma nominal, you could use 7 of those strips run in series to 4 on the low end as we have to round up to get over the voltage threshold of 142v.

So what about old drivers you may have kicking around such as the HLG series

Well so long as they can output that base 19.5v for the 280mm and 560mm ones or 39v for the 1120mm one you will be able to use them.

Examples would be any of the HLG-_ _H-20A or B series or HLG-__H-42 A or B series drivers , with the 36A’s and less likely the 54A’s possibly being able to be used, but they would have to be measured. Saying that specs sheets list that the voltages on those later ones will put out less than what we need, but and a big one here, the HLG drivers specifically the A series are capable of being over driven with the internal Vo potentiometer screw. So there is a possibility that they can supply the voltages we need for these strips and is really easy to figure out if you have a multimeter and a small phillips screwdriver. You just crank the voltage screw and measure the output.

Now saying that the HLG drivers in order to figure out how many we can run it comes down to division of the rated current range, which is no different than the XLG drivers but just on the voltage side.

So say we had a old HLG-240H-20A driver, voltage range is 18.6-21.4v with 6-12a current adjustable range.

insert math… 12a / 0.7a “700ma” = 17 strips of the 560mm, factor in some potential over driving if so desired at say 0.8-0.9a and we have 15 -13 strips

Wiring for these would be a straight parallel configuration for the 560mm ones and if using the 280mm ones which you would have essential double the amount of aka 12a/0.35a = 34 strips.

Redundancy wise if a strip got broken completely like the previous example, the current that that strip used would just be dissipated to the other strips evenly which wouldn’t be much 17 strips minus 1 = 16, and 700ma / 16 = 43.75ma increase to each strip, again minor, but the downside is the high amperage your running at “think big sparks” if shorted

So saying that yeah always keep safety in mind and do you best to avoid potential issues if your building an array.

But there are a few drivers out there capable of running these strips, i suggest the XLG series specifically the L format of them.

35 Likes

Well, that was an easy understandable read, compared to the leanghty ones I just read! :smiley:

Thanks alot Spark’s! :slight_smile:

8 Likes

I would still consider that lengthy from this one who babbles a lot lol

But may help some other.

10 Likes

Boom, dropping the knowledge! :boom:

11 Likes

Could you go to my thread and see the Quantum board DIY kit I posted.
Tell me what I would need in the Bridgelux to match it??? 620 watts Kit and board look sweet, but 720 bucks is 720 bucks!!!

IF you want to and have time that is!!!

5 Likes