(Youāre getting in the middle of a big protracted fight you know)
4 Likes
(should i walk away?)
1 Like
So botrytis spores in the air can infect your grow if you run suboptimal conditions, but powdery mildew cannot? They are both fungi, both plant pests, reproduce by spores germinating in humid conditionsā¦why is that, Joe?
Lol folks listen to Joe you canāt get PM if thereās no infected plants in your grow. Spores donāt travel in the air like mycologists will tell you. Donāt worry about it, ever, youāre safe. I can specifically tell you thatās not true from personal experience, but hey, I might just be a guy you donāt know lying on the internet.
Yes, two adult men have in fact been arguing about mildew for a year or more. Itās a cold war that occasionally boils overā¦you may join the Joe Bloc or the Vernal Union. Welcome to OG hahaha nice to have you here. If you really really like talking about weed, youāre in the right place.
3 Likes
Iām doing a study on him, itās interesting to me why people believe in things that arenāt true, then refuse to verify the truth when they are told what it is. Really fascinating to me.
Lemme know when that study youāre definitely actually doing gets published, lol. We wait with bated breath.
āWhy Everyone Who Disagrees with Me is Crazy: A Super Serial Case Studyā
1 Like
no man. You know weāve been rotating on this planet together for a year right? Itās about confirmation bias. Iām just real curious about how far it goes, when it comes to simple tests to verify the truth. I know we hit it off wrong on the protocol 0 thread man, but that info has already passed into the masses. Canāt you just get a single little clone plant put it in containment then let the humidity climb and see what happens? Iām not asking you to destroy your crop, a simple test will do.
1 Like
I have done that. Itās called growing. Iāve gotten PM several times. Including times with no outside genetics or plants in the garden, nothing but seed plantsā¦and plants too close together, inadequate ventilation, leaves touching, high humidity. I donāt need to build an experiment to prove that. Iāve seen that firsthand. IDK how thatās soooo crazy of an idea. Iām not the first person to get mildew.
You never answered my question about the botrytis. You said high humidity gave you botrytis. If botrytis spores can easily get into your grow in the air and germinate, why canāt powdery mildew spores? Why? What makes them any different? Indulge us, please.
1 Like
ok vernal Iāll let your confirmation bias rest. There is some final advice from someone way smarter than me.
āThe first principle is that you must not fool yourself ā and you are the easiest person to fool.ā Richard Feynman
If you actually want to talk about botrytis, we can do that. If itās just to indulge your fantasies yo forget that crap. The denial is too deep, you can only change if you want to.
1 Like
Thatās a fun way to dodge the question. If airborne botrytis spores can infect your plants, so can powdery mildew.
2 Likes
Hey this is a victory - he just admitted thereās someone smarter than him.
3 Likes
Sorry not gonna read everything but just want to say Iāve had some of my best grows in high humidity with a swamp cooler. During veg Iād hit 70%- 75% rh and during flower it was 45%-55% and never get PM.
I notice PM comes from cramping plants, lack of light penetration to lower leafs and bad air flow. Once itās infested high humidity helps it spread faster.
I donāt know everything so I canāt say 100% that Iām right and fight about it but Iāve been experimenting for almost 20 years 
2 Likes
Ah vernal brother, you seriously answered all my questions and completed the study. My advice is to never try the study on your friends they get really angry when you confront their bias. Oh I learned that before I arrived here on overgrow hah hah mistake number one.
Ironically you could apply the humidity advice to the botrytis case, but not mildew. I find that fact to be a really interesting coincidence. If you want to talk about botrytis, we can. Just know that powdery mildew and botrytis are two completely different organisms. There is no way you are going to compare the two, thatās my advice.
Thatās a lot more words to dodge the question again.
Both airborne fungal spores that infect plants and germinate in high humidity. How can you get botrytis from airborne spores but not powdery mildew? Sure powdery mildew also produces sporesā¦but donāt worry you canāt get them because reasons!
1 Like
errr what? Thatās like comparing yeast to powdery mildew. How do you think there is a comparison, really?
orā¦ youāre trying to get me to claim that humidity, not exposure to the replicating pathogen Botrytis cinerea is the cause? Because exposure is definitely the initial problem, but it can be prevented from replicating with humidity control.
Hey I got a radical claim youāll never see in print, for another decade. Unless you search really hard. Plant immune response to powdery mildew is to generate small quantities of sulfur to fend it off.
Ahem-
Iām ready to wade into this oneā¦
Bud rot aināt the same as PM
Just in case anyone thinks Iām a college educated scientist, after dropping that knowledge bomb-
Truth is, I figured that out through experienceā¦
Hawaii outdoor = bud rot
Some strains get it, others, not so much
Dispo clones = Pm
Some strains get it, others, not so much
Growing plants with a swamp cooler, and not pruning when itās too hot can cause all kinds of problems, especially if your fan just quitā¦
But sometimes you just gotta roll with what you got, and hope for the best 
Iāve seen grown men cry over bud rot-
PM, is a real PITAā¦
1 Like
It can be a pain until you understand it, the important part is using sulfur to finish it off. You can do it in one application, but I recommend two. mix 1 tablespoon of high yield(90%+) in a liter of water and soak the plants. Two applications two weeks apart itās fucking done. If you sulfur the clones from the dispensary theyāll never infest you 
3 Likes
2 Likes