I do not have the specific details on the spirit train specifically. Please reach out to the co-op originators and the co-op action group for deeper details on the conclusions made.
Bodhi does seem to keep a stash of retired lines that he’ll make available pseudo randomly. I’ve seen things pop-up that we know as being retired or lost from time to time. There is some discussion examples around a similar conflict from a number of years ago in the Bodhi response thread (linked above) where late in a run on something, I forget, it suddenly popped up on GLG.
Historically, we’ve had some examples of where it was understood that a certain cross was retired (no longer being made available) and no longer in the retail channels only to see it re-appear some many months later. Those types of situation typically require thought, consideration, and discussion that sometimes leads to reaching out to the strain originator.
Despite that, it’s a bit ancillary to the discussion at hand. Point is, there is a desire to avoid executing runs on current lines known (as per the breeder) or suspect (e.g. recent) unless some hurdles are cleared and verified.
This is not a limitation on individuals doing their own thing. No one is stopping anyone. What you own is what you own and you most certainly should be able to do with that as you please.
Though, within the OG community, there needs to be some care taken to avoid becoming the pirate ship within the greater community. There are limitations to consider as we desire to maintain a respectful face within the larger community, to avoid the drama, and to avoid interfering with breeder livelihoods. Primarily, the idea is rare, discontinued, retired, or exceedingly difficult to obtain lines (last one is perhaps a bit grey) are generally good to go as it achieves a number of goals while minimizing the risk of stepping on toes. We’ve also have had, while relatively rare, runs aborted or not included within distribution because of a conflict.
It’s difficult to not sound negative and no one wants to tamper such ambition. Some situations do need to get untangled from time to time. What is being pointed out is that some of what is being considered needs additional clarity. The ideas here are great along with a number of thoughtful comments. The desire and effort to develop and participate in a co-op run is awesome with any shared results receiving a great deal of attention and is very much appreciated by the OG community overall. It is a cornerstone towards building strong relationships, team efforts, and an overall stronger community. Truly those that participate is something to admire and look up to.