Hi @VRG
There are a couple of things that seem essential to The Cheese Stories. Mainly, it is clarity (or lack there-of). It is a very muddy subject, as I’m sure you’re aware.
San may have mis-spoke when he said that Blues is a cross of Exodus and Blueberry. It was certainly a clone going around, and if not the “real” Exodus Cheese, then it was most probably a cross to Exodus with something else. What that (father) was is a question. Perhaps a Blueberry. It was, after all, called Blues (as well as Livers). Nevertheless, let’s suffice it to say that it is not known what the exact parentage of the Blues was, except, maybe, that it had Exodus as the mother.
That you worked with the Blues, and knowingly used a Blueberry, makes UGORG Blues line certainly have Blueberry in it. This is now fact from the source.
We know that Silas used the UGORG Blues in his Lost Skunk. He selected a UGORG Blues male, and crossed it with the Exodus Cheese. My guess is that he wanted to get Cheese into seed form, and used the Blues because it probably had Exodus in it, making it a partial back-cross.
I’m also pretty sure that Silas created Lost Skunk before you created UGORG#1. Weather you saw the potential of what he did, or not, is your story. You did know him, and ran in the same circles, and you are aware of this.
We can say for sure that his selection of a male used for Lost Skunk differed from your selection, even tho they were both UGORG Blues males.
You can state your opinion about UGORG#1, but it is obviously biased (in that you created that line and have an commercial interest in saying that it is a perfect representation of this or that).
By my estimation, multiple side-by-sides should occur, and a comparison follow suit on each.
If anyone wants a pack of the Lost Skunk I repro’ed on here, DM me with an address and I"ll get some seeds to you.
I also invite @VRG and @JAWS to make the same offer, so that we can start to look at the similarities and differences, and thus have a real conversation and learn from it. Let them speak for themselves.
There are a lot of companies wanting to capitalize on Cheese - and the preceding name of true authenticity - Exodus (and which was given out freely). This market-driven approach muddies the cheese. It inserts a lot of bias and self-promoting opinion (not really the true intent of it’s originator).
Let’s strip it down.
(PS to add)
I am trying to moderate this thread for clarity and accuracy, as the Cheese Stories get really crazy.
That said, I have a lot of respect for both you @VRG, and @JAWS. You two have done a tremendous amount of work and it has current and historical significance. Your contributions are profound. I want to add this because it’s true, but also so you know where I"m coming from